Supergirl: Melissa Benoist Wears the Cape Well

Melissa Benoit as Supergirl

On a completely comic book geek level, Melissa Benoist wears the super cape well as her portrayal as Supergirl, aka Kara Danvers.  The actress has a personable and uber attractive presence who feels like “the girl next  door.” This gal has super powers and as cousin to Superman, aka Clark Kent and even employs the “glasses” disguise with similar success to her super relative.   The show’s pilot premiered to high figures and it is entertaining. There are a few problems with the show however.

Not least of which is IGN’s massive crusade to make this show a hit. Since the series premiered at this year’s Comic Con the publication has been beating the Supergirl drum.  Apart from the site’s singleminded attempt to sing the praises of this small screen superhero, other reviewers gave the show’s pilot a thumbs up back in May which seems to bode well for the CBS series.

Sadly there are things that feel a bit hackneyed. Jimmy “James” Olsen looking like an escapee from the local gym with biceps so huge it’s a wonder they could find shirts to fit him being one. Merced Brooks as the “cub reporter” (turned photojournalist apparently) does not really work but for whatever reason the show’s producers and creators have opted to make Olsen not a reporter as well as  less bumbling and more beefcake. 

Calista Flockhart as Cat Grant, the shrew news publisher who hates cold latte is another odd choice. Perhaps the best thing that can be said of Flockhart is that she looks nowhere near her age (50).  She does exude the type of manner one associates with a Perry White, but in a designer skirt, and with a hint of maliciousness that dear old blustery Perry never had.

*Sidenote* Am I the only one that really wanted Kara to blast that latte with her heat laser eyes to warm it up? 

The entire DEO bit, with douche leader Hank Henshaw (David Harewood) was annoying and felt forced. Sure it gave Alex Danvers a great excuse to intervene (and be a major character in the show) but overall it introduced another faction for Kara, as Supergirl,  to battle. 

Certainly a good story requires struggle but why does our female role model have to fight everyone to be a superhero?  Her own internal fight for identity and purpose was not enough?  External fights of identity aside, the more important is the question of just why does Supergirl get cut by a weapon that is not powered by a form of Kryptonite?

Granted, this viewer’s recollection of just what Kryptonite did what to Superman is a little hazy but having grown up on the tight wearing superheroes exploits, it seems that nothing could actually harm the big guy or his “cousin” apart from that pesky mineral from his and her home planet.

Still, apart from minor annoyances that the creators opted to make the pilot more a “coming of age” thing versus a realization that super means super…damn it, and that the female version of the Man of Steel will fight crime and rescue planes if she wants to.

Speaking of Man of Steel, it is interesting to note that Clark Kent’s cousin, in keeping with the Zack Snyder re-imaging of Superman, is also placed in a seaside setting in the very brief glance at her childhood.  A nod and wink to small screen Superman had Dean  Cain as the father figure of Kara’s adoptive family. Nice touch.

On the plus side, the stunt action looked great and Benoist looks perfect in the “suit” and she, along with her stunt double look equally impressive in the fight scenes and if there is ever one moment where one falls in love with Melissa as Supergirl, it has to be in the pilot’s opening airplane scene.

How can one not adore a superhero, who is just learning what she is capable of, who spots the approaching bridge and gripping the bottom of the aircraft more firmly says, with an annoyed and harassed tone, “Oh come on.”

A priceless moment that meant, from that point on, almost anything could happen in terms of plot rightly or wrongly and all would be forgiven. Benoist wears the cape well and manages to fly the fine line between helpful “everywoman” from another planet and the geeky “How cool was that” heroine who is getting a kick out of fulfilling her destiny.

Supergirl is part of the CBS roster and airs Mondays.  Despite a number of flaws, Melissa Benoist pulls it off with a flair that impresses and delights. Tune in and see what you think.

Author: Mike's Film Talk

Former Actor, Former Writer, Former Journalist, USAF Veteran, Former Member Nevada Film Critics Society

2 thoughts on “Supergirl: Melissa Benoist Wears the Cape Well”

  1. Some thoughts and comments:
    “why does Supergirl get cut by a weapon that is not powered by a form of Kryptonite?”

    The weapon is more than just an ax made on earth. It’s Kryptonian, and I think they alluded to it being nuclear powered. She’s not invincible. If it’s anything like Smallville, she’ll be nearly invincible but will suffer minor damage that heals within a minute or so of exposure to sunlight. The fact that she can suffer some damage makes it easier for the audience to relate to her.

    “Speaking of Man of Steel, it is interesting to note that Clark Kent’s cousin, in keeping with the Zack Snyder re-imaging of Superman, is also placed in a seaside setting in the very brief glance at her childhood.”

    I don’t remember the seaside setting in Man of Steel. I thought it was Smallville, KS, in that movie, too. Did I misunderstand your comment, or did I miss something in the movie?

    “A nod and wink to small screen Superman had Dean Cain as the father figure of Kara’s adoptive family. Nice touch.”

    Helen Slater is a nice addition, too, as she previously played Supergirl on the big screen. Smallville was good for reaching out to past characters, also, as Dean Cain (Curtis Knox), Teri Hatcher (Lois’s mom), Christopher Reeve (Dr. Swann), Margot Kidder (an associate of Swann’s), had recurring or one-shot roles and Annette O’Toole (Martha Kent) had a lead role. And that reminds me, Helen Slater also played Clark’s Kryptonian mother Lara-El on Smallville.

    One thing I found weird was when Kara’s sister showed up with the relic from her ship–besides the fact that it wasn’t transported via armed guard given it was an alien artifact–was Kara saying “That writing is Kryptonese.” Never heard that term before. It’s always been Kryptonian. Peculiar. I don’t know if there’s some weird copyright thing (seems bizarre to care) or if it’s just an error. Almost was weird as not referring to Superman as “Superman,” but always just “the big guy” or just “him.”

    She forgave her sister *awfully quick* for betraying her, too. For all Alex knew, Hank Jerkshaw could have cut up Kara and dissected her. Nice one, Alex. Be glad Kara didn’t teach you how to fly…the hard way.

    I really enjoyed the show overall. Melissa Benoist is charming, funny, and gorgeous. Some dialogue was corny, but the “Oh, come on!” at the bridge was funny! My plate is getting pretty full with superhero shows now. Check your review next week!


    1. Hey! Thanks for some awesome feedback! The seaside reference was alluding the the fishing village setting in the film, it’s been ages since I watched it and referred an older article, seaside should have followed a reference to the village…my bad. But like I said, I’m a little rusty on my Super-Verse, apart from the multicolored versions of Kryptonite. The show had me at “Oh come on.” From that point on I could forgive pretty much anything, even Supergirl forgiving her annoying sister…Thanks for mentioning Slater, I missed her in my geeky excited at seeing Cain… 🙂


Let me know what you think!

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Health Tips Now

Health and Diet Tips


"I hold it, that a little rebellion, now and then, is a good thing, and as necessary in the political world as storms in the physical."

%d bloggers like this: