In American Horror Story: Freak Show the Pink Cupcake episode was the day that Elsa’s music died. Her splendid rendition of Life on Mars fell on deaf ears and the crowd booed the singer’s performance and threw popcorn at her. Mars leaves the stage in tears, confused and upset as Jimmy, aka Lobster Boy, leads her away. Meanwhile Stanley sits in the audience with a smile on his face, one that looks suspiciously satisfied. It certainly seems like his plans are going very well.